$9 Flat Rate ShippingFor Customers in the U.S.
Monthly DropsExclusive First Access For Email List Subscribers
Free shippingOn all orders over $150 in the USA
Mystery Collections

Mystery Collections

Hi Little Leaf! If you love mysteries, you're in the right place! Mystery packs are here in all kinds of themes & sizes! Select a theme you love, and the price point you’re comfortable with, and I’ll do the rest! Get ready to be surprised with items picked to fit your aesthetic!

Check out our past collections of Mystery Boxes and Pen Packs in the Extinct Section!
48 products
Sold Out
Quick view
Love Potion Mystery Pen Packs
$25.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Fated Lovers Mystery Pen Packs
$25.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Protectress Medusa Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Artemis' Alchemy Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Demeter's Return of Happiness Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Aphrodite's Admirer Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Quick view
Aurora Borealis Mystery Pen Packs
$25.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Mystery Pen Pack
from $15.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Mystery Washi Tape Pack
from $15.00
Sold Out
Quick view
BLACKOUT Kraken - Mystery Pen Packs
$25.00
Sold Out
Quick view
BookTok Mystery Theme Set
$40.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Cozy Bookshop Cafe Mystery Theme Set
$85.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Herbal Kitchen Witch Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Mushroom Mania Mystery Theme Set
$55.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Forest Forager Mystery Theme Set
$85.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Black Bear & Berry Mystery Theme Set
$55.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Forest Floor Mystery Theme Set
$80.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Mystery Crystal Statement Piece Box
$195.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Green Botanical Witch Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Hedge Witch Mystery Theme Set
$100.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Cottagecore Mystery Pen Packs
$15.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Bee Keeping Notes Mystery Theme Pack
$40.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Hummingbird + Honey Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Busy Bee Mystery Theme Set
$105.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Bugs + Beetles Mystery Theme Set
$70.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Butterfly + Moth Mystery Theme Set
$55.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Botanical Gardens Mystery Pen Packs
$15.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Pot of Gold - Mystery Pen Pack
$17.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Galaxy Mystery Pen Packs
$25.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Midnight Moth Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Mystery Pen Packs - Jewel Tones Limited Edition
$25.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Dark Academia Mystery Theme Set
$95.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Victorian Vampire Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Serpent Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Sold Out
Quick view
The Hermit Mystery Theme Set
$55.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Rain Rain Don't Go Away Mystery Theme Set
$60.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Deep Sea Siren Mystery Theme Set
$85.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Whale Watcher Mystery Theme Set
$75.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Miyazaki's Meadow Mystery Theme Set
$85.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Golden Hour Mystery Theme Set
$65.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Self Care Mystery Theme Set
$65.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Book-Lover's Mini Essentials Mystery Theme Pack
$25.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Mystery Crystal Spheres
$5.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Mystery Crystal Worry Stones
$10.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Mystery Pack - 100% Custom Picked for YOU
$200.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Moonlit Manor Mystery Theme Box
$250.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Frankie's Wholesome Halloween Mystery Theme Box
$195.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Halloween Mystery Pen Packs
$31.00